I'm going to be hosting my first beer tasting this coming weekend and wanted to get some advice on the order to pour the brews. I'll make an attempt at what I'm thinking and if anyone has some other suggestions, please chime in. My homebrew (Amber Ale 4.2% ABV, very low IBU) Revolution Cross of Gold Duvel Hopslam Sucaba '13 Dark Lord '12 Bourbon County Coffee '12 thanks!
i think that's a pretty solid order (from mild to extreme flavors, kinda).... i might switch the Sucuba and the DL, just to have the 2 BA beers together, an DL is almost as different from BCBS as sucuba is). Other than that they are all pretty vastly different, so it should be a roller-coaster ride for your mouth (nothing wrong with that!).
I'd order them by impact on the palate from the hops and dark roast malt, much as you have, but would personally swap the order of the sucaba and the hopslam since for my tastes the hop bitterness shows a bit more in the hopslam (dipa) than in an English barleywine like sucaba. Be sure to have lots of water and unsalted crackers for between beers to cleanse the palate.