Well, liquor store shelf aged... Just wondering, should I stay away from the 2011 Goose Island Sofie I found on the shelf at my local bottle shop? Obviously, it wasn't stored under even close to ideal conditions, but it's still a year of aging. I'm just looking for a decent saison for the holidays, and if the positives outweigh the negatives I'll try the 2011, otherwise I'll grab a 2012. The store even had some current BCBS available! Any help on this will be appreciated. TIA, gg
I strongly prefer one year on Sofie to fresh. If both vintages were sitting next to each other on the shelf, I'd choose the older bottle every time.
I had a 2011 Sofie about a month ago and thought it was fantastic. My daughter's name is Sofie and I was considering finding some older bottles, but I didn't know how well they hold up.
I had a 2010 Sofie earlier this year that was absolutely outstanding. Not sure where it starts to fall off, but 2 years did wonderful things.
Aged Sofie........................................................................................................................is delicious!
Picks up just a touch of funk after a couple years. I still have a 2010 hidden in the depths of my basement that I'm looking forward to cracking in a few years.
I have 2 2011 Sofies from their recall, which is the only reason they're still in the bottles and not in my belly. Hoping a little age might help...?
We had a 2010 recently and it was amazing! It ages really well. If I could find more I would grab and store them.
2009 Sofie didn't hold up, but my suspicion lay with the screw cap. 2010 held up fantastically, thank god they switched to pry off.